Pages

Showing posts with label Promises. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Promises. Show all posts

Thursday, October 8, 2015

Donie's Ireland daily news BLOG update

November general election most likely as Kenny set to reveal party’s key pledge

Radical welfare changes on payments to benefit working families, says Taoiseach Kenny.

 Enda & Joan joined at the hips?   
Taoiseach Enda Kenny, who is leaning strongly towards calling a November general election, will tonight unveil a key element of Fine Gael’s manifesto by pledging no one will receive more in welfare payments than they could earn at work.
Mr Kenny’s decision to announce the “working family payment” plan at the Dublin Chamber of Commerce annual dinner will further fuel speculation he intends to call a general election shortly after the budget.
It means a November election is now very much on the cards but the precise date will depend on the timetable for getting the Finance Bill and the Social Welfare Bill through the Dáil.
Officials in the Department of Finance have already been told to draw up a slimmed down version of the Finance Bill giving effect to the budget changes that can be passed quickly through the Dáil.
Kenny’s speech?
In his speech tonight Mr Kenny will pledge to change the welfare system to ensure people at work can be sure of being better off than if they were on welfare. A similar commitment was included in the British Conservative Party’s successful general election platform earlier this year.
A new “working family payment” will be aimed in particular at families with one or more children.
Mr Kenny will outline how it will be targeted at low-income families by supplementing, on a graduated basis, the income of a household while at the same time incentivising more hours and full-time work.
A key feature of the payment will be to better align it with existing jobseeker supports aimed at creating a seamless transition from welfare to work for families while removing many of the welfare traps facing families with existing schemes such as the family income supplement.
The Taoiseach will outline why, in his opinion, such a scheme is needed.
“It is clear that the lack of a job in Ireland is by far and away the leading cause of inequality in our society. There are still far too many traps that lock parents in particular into welfare dependency. In many cases for couples with children work simply does not pay.
A radical approach.
“This is why the next government needs to adopt a far more radical approach if we are to successfully help jobless households back into work.
“For these reasons I expect the theme of radical welfare reform, along with lowering the tax burden on low- and middle-income workers, to make work pay will be a key election issue,” he is due to say.
The Taoiseach will also outline why he believes the next government needs to do more for households trapped in a cycle of poverty in which nobody is working. He will claim the “working family payment” will be the helping hand up on to the career ladder for many unemployed parents.
Tánaiste Joan Burton is strongly opposed to an early election. A meeting of the parliamentary Labour party last night heard a “unanimous” preference from TDs and Senators for an election next spring.
At the meeting, Ms Burton repeated her position that the election should be held next year. TDs and Senators told the meeting it was imperative the banking inquiry complete its work and the legislation to give effect to public sector pay rises agreement was passed.
“There was a real sense of frustration that there is a feeding frenzy around November,” said one TD.
“It is starting to undermine the image of a unified and coherent Government. There is a real feeling the Taoiseach should come out and talk to Joan. It is starting to look embarrassing to us at this stage.”

Thousands apply for grant without paying their water bills

Alan Kelly asks Irish people not to ‘pull a fast one’ over the new water conservation payment

  

At least tens of thousands of people have applied for the water conservation grant without having paid their water bills, an analysis of the figures shows.

The water conservation grant amounts to €100 and was introduced by the Government to enable households to “adopt a more environmentally friendly approach” to water usage in the home.
Minister for the Environment Alan Kelly has urged people not to “pull a fast one” by applying for the grant without paying their bills..
As of tonight, 732,800 grant applications had been received, while the number of people who registered with Irish Water by the deadline of June 30th stands at 1.3 million.
This amounts to an overall application rate of 56%.
Speaking on Wednesday, Michael McNicholas, chief executive of Ervia, the parent company forIrish Water, said that almost 54 per cent of those who have registered have paid their bills.

That percentile amounts to 702,000 people.

This figure means that at least 30,800 people have applied for the conservation grant without paying their bill.
The deadline?
The deadline to apply for the grant expires at midnight on Thursday night.
The Department of Social Protection released a statement on Wednesday urging those who have paid their water bills to apply for the grant.
The statement said a total of 395,000 households have already received their grant payment.
It is expected that all payments will be made by the end of October.
Approximately 363,000 calls on the subject have been received by the department’s helpline to date, with about 50,000 of those coming in the last two days.
Due to the high volume of calls, an additional helpline has been made available.
The numbers are: 076-1087890, 02-12065880, or 1890-100043. The lines will be open from 8.30am until midnight.

Electric Ireland to reduce home electricity prices by 2%

Move comes after Bord Gáis Energy shaved 2.5% off its residential gas prices

   
Electric Ireland is to reduce its standard electricity prices for residential customers by an average of 2%.
Electric Ireland has announced it will reduce its standard electricity prices for residential customers by an average of 2% from next month.
The reduction, which comes into effect on November 16th, will benefit the average residential customer with a saving of €24.11 (including VAT) per year.
Must shop around’
Minister for Energy Alex White welcomed the move and said customers should “shop around” to ensure they are getting the best deal possible.
“Electric Ireland’s welcome move on prices, which comes in advance of increased winter energy demand, will be welcomed by families and businesses,” he said.
“It is the second such move by a major energy supplier in recent weeks, which suggests that conditions are right for other companies to follow. This is good news and I would encourage all consumers to shop around to ensure that they get the best price available.
“Even if consumers don’t want to change supplier they can call their supplier and ensure they have the best package on offer.”
In September, Bord Gáis Energy announced plans to shave 2.5% off its residential gas prices in a move which saw the average consumer make an annual saving of just over €20.
It also announced its intention to cut its unit rate of electricity by a further 2 per cent which would lead to electricity bill savings of €24.34 a year.
Household bills
Earlier this year, Mr White held a series of meetings with the energy suppliers to discuss the speed with which wholesale energy price reductions were being reflected in household bills.
Electric Ireland executive director Jim Dollard said the company was “happy to be able to continue to reduce prices for our electricity customers again this winter”.
“This reduction, combined with last year’s reduction, means the average residential bill will have reduced by almost €50,” he said.
“We are committed to offering the best value products in a very competitive marketplace and I believe today’s announcement will be good news for our 1.2 million residential customers.”

Irish men drink and smoke more than women,

says a health survey

Healthy Ireland study raises concerns over risky sex, snacking and low levels of exercise

   
While smoking is in decline, drinking alcohol remains a majority pursuit, engaged in by 76% of the population. Just over half of us drink at least weekly.
Significant variations in wellbeing between men and women and across social classes emerge from the first national survey of people’s health in almost a decade.
Men drink, binge drink and smoke more, but are also more likely to be highly active, and heavier, than women, according to the Healthy Ireland survey.
Wealthier groups smoke less but drink more alcohol in general than people in the most deprived areas, where binge drinking is higher.
The survey published by the Department of Health carries encouraging signs for the nation’s health, including falling smoking rates, a levelling off in obesity and positive levels of good mental health and social connectedness.
There are also numerous areas of concern, including high levels of risky sexual activity, binge drinking and snacking, and low levels of physical exercise.
Smoking is twice as common in deprived areas compared to more affluent groups, and levels of obesity among young women are twice those among male 15- to 24-year-olds.
More than 7,500 interviews were carried out for the survey, the first study of this size since 2007.
A reason for optimism?
Minister for Health Leo Varadkar said the findings provided some reason for optimism but also highlighted risks such as the prospect of a dramatic risk in chronic diseases.
The survey expresses concern that a majority of men who recently had sex with men did not use a condom. However, the study presents evidence of “more widespread risky behaviour”, with 17% of all those having sex with someone outside of a steady relationship not using any form of contraception.
“The exposure to risk for these individuals is significant,” it says.
Most of us describe our health in positive terms, with 85 per cent saying it is good or very good. Yet one-quarter of the population has a long-standing illness, and over half of this group experience limitations in everyday activities.
High blood pressure and back pain are the most common ailments, both experienced by one in eight people. One in 10 of us suffer from arthritis or an allergy, according to the survey.
On average we visit the GP 4.3 times a year, and women are more frequent attenders than men.
However, the overall figure masks a substantial variation between people with medical cards (6.3 visits a year) and those without any card (2.9 visits).
Smoking prevalence is falling, and Ireland is on the way to being tobacco-free, according to the survey. The proportion of regular smokers has dropped from 24% in the last national survey in 2007 to 19%.
Occasional smoking is also down, from 5 per cent to 4%.
People in the most deprived areas are over twice as likely to be smokers compared to the most affluent group – 35% against 16%.
While smoking is in decline, drinking alcohol remains a majority pursuit, engaged in by 76% of the population. Just over half of us drink at least weekly.
Men drink more frequently than women, and more over-55s drink weekly than among other age groups.
Drinking to excess
The survey says drinking is a core part of Irish life and “more worryingly” drinking to excess on a regular basis is also commonplace.
Four out of 10 drinkers in Ireland drink to harmful levels on a monthly basis, and one-fifth do so on a weekly basis.
“Given that one in six of those drinking at harmful levels felt in the past 12 months that their drinking harmed their health, it is likely that many of those drinking in that way are unaware of the risks associated with it.”
Alcohol consumption rises with social class but binge drinking is highest in the most deprived areas, the survey also finds.
It uses the WHO definition of binge drinking as six or more standard drinks on a single occasion, equivalent to three pints of beer. The drinks industry considers this threshold too low.
Two-thirds of the population are not sufficiently active, a negative finding compounded by the fact that people spend on average more than five hours a day sitting. Four in 10 men are highly active, but only 24% of women are.
Physical activity is not a cure-all for weight issues, however; 23% of those who are obese are highly active.
On diet, one in four people say they eat the recommended five portions of fruit and vegetables a day, while 22% say they don’t eat fruit or vegetables daily. Snacking is widespread, with 62% saying they eat an average of two snacks a day.
Sugared drinks.
Some 15% drink sugar-sweetened drinks but, worrying, consumption is twice this level among young people aged 15-24 years.
Men are more likely to be overweight than women and overall, 37% of the population has a normal weight, 37% are overweight and 23% are obese. Obesity is highest in more deprived areas.
The report finds encouraging levels of good mental health and reasonable levels of social connectedness in the population. Rubbish or litter lying around, and house break-ins, emerged as major sources of concern in this respect.

Rare Wood house-harmless spider discovered in Co Antrim cliffs

  

The funnel-web spider prefers the outdoors compared its relative the house spider.

A rare spider has been found in Northern Ireland for the first time – but fear not, it is completely harmless.
The Wood house-spider, or malthonica silvestris, discovered on cliffs at Whitehead in Co Antrim, is a close relative of house spiders that people are complaining about bugging their homes at the moment.
However, it is normally half the size of the eight-legged creepy crawlies that send many of us into histrionics.
And unlike the typical house spider, this spider – which has only been recorded in Cork so far on the island – prefers to live in crooks and crevices in natural outdoor surroundings rather than in the warmth of your home.
One theory on the creature’s movements may be that it is venturing north because of the warmer weather.
Adam Mantell, Buglife’s Northern Ireland Officer is the entomologist who found and identified the spider during a survey said: “This is a really exciting discovery.
“Not only is this the first record for Northern Ireland, but it is very rare across the rest of Ireland too.
“With two out of three of our bugs in decline and so much wildlife disappearing from our countryside, it’s brilliant to have some good news for once, and add another spider to the list of species found in Northern Ireland.”

Sneezing Monkeys & ‘Walking Fish’ are a fascinating new species discovered

  
A monkey that sneezes whenever it rains, a fish that can survive out of water for four days and a venomous pit viper that is as lovely to look at as a piece of jewelry: These are just a few of the hundreds of new species discovered over the past few years in the diverse but highly threatened region of the east Himalayas.
Between 2009 and 2014, scientists discovered a total of 211 new species in the region, which stretches from central Nepal in the west to Myanmar in the east and includes the kingdom of Bhutan, as well as parts of northeast India and southern Tibet.
An average of 34 new plant and animal species have been discovered annually in the region for the past six years, according to a newly released report from the World Wildlife Fund (WWF).
“I am excited that the region — home to a staggering number of species including some of the most charismatic fauna — continues to surprise the world with the nature and pace of species discovery,” Ravi Singh, CEO of WWF-India and chair of the WWF Living Himalayas Initiative, said in a statement. [101 Animal Shots You’ll Go Wild Over]
‘Charismatic fauna’
Among the most impressive new species included in the WWF’s report is the sneezing monkey, which scientists nicknamed “Snubby.” The unusual critter lives in a remote region in northern Myanmar, an area of rugged mountains and dense forests. Snubby has an upturned nose (hence its nickname) that has a tendency to collect rainwater, causing the black-and-white–hued monkey to sneeze when it rains. To avoid sneezing fits, the animals spend rainy days with their heads tucked between their knees, according to the WWF.
Northern Myanmar is also home to a tiny but terrifying new species of fish, Danionella dracula, which is the size of a minnow but has pointy fangs jutting out from its jaws. Another strange fish from the eastern Himalayas is Channa andrao, a snakehead fish with some truly strange qualities. The vibrant blue fish can “walk” on land by wriggling around on its belly. The fish’s ability to breath air means it can live on land for a few days before returning to its freshwater habitat.
The only new reptile discovered in the eastern Himalayas since 2009, the bejeweled lance-headed pit viper (Protobothrops himalayansus), is also something special. Even if you don’t like snakes, it’s hard to deny this venomous serpent’s beauty. The reptile’s striking, diamondlike pattern and red-brown coloration give the snake a bejeweled quality.
‘At a crossroads’
All of these newly discovered species may sound like great news to anyone who appreciates biodiversity, but the WWF report also highlights the many threats facing the east Himalayas. Perhaps the most pressing is climate change, with the threat of habitat loss caused by deforestation, development and overgrazing not far behind.
Only 25 percent of the original habitats in the region remain intact, according to the WWF report, which found that rapid development has affected the vast majority of the region’s lands.
“The eastern Himalayas is at a crossroads. Governments can decide whether to follow the current path towards fragile economies that do not fully account for environmental impacts, or take an alternative path towards greener, more sustainable economic development,” Sami Tornikoski, leader of the WWF Living Himalayas Initiative, said in a statement.
In total, the Himalayas are home to an estimated 10,000 plant species and 300 mammal species. Nearly 1,000 different species of birds call the region home, along with hundreds of species of reptiles, amphibians and freshwater fish. In the new WWF report alone, more than 130 new species of plants were discovered in the area.
The challenge that organizations like the WWF face is to both conserve the species that scientists have already identified and protect a region that likely shelters even more creatures and plants waiting to be discovered.  

Sunday, June 30, 2013

Donie's news Ireland today Saturday

Ten changes that Enda Kenny should do to reform Government in Ireland now 

 

The Dáil purports to do a 21st century job but shelters behind 19th century privileges.

The Taoiseach, Enda Kenny, likes to use business metaphors but our Dáil operates on principles that no business could afford and he is fond of using business metaphors. “Ireland is open for business.” It is “the best small country in the world to do business in”.
That declared focus might raise hopes that the Coalition would seek to have parliament adopt some of the efficiencies of business. We have a Dáil that operates on principles that no modern business could tolerate. Its productivity is poor. Its working disciplines are lax. It purports to do a 21st century job while sheltering behind 19th century privileges.
If the Coalition were in earnest about reform of parliament, here are 10 things that they could do to make the Oireachtas more effective, more accountable and better respected by the people it serves.
  • 1 They should put up a proposal to modify Article 16.5 of the Constitution which, through the Electoral Acts, prescribes our current system of proportional representation. It was devised almost 90 years ago to address the democratic sensitivities of a new State emerging from civil war. Nowadays, it makes messenger boys and fixers of TDs. It is a breeding box for the worst kinds of clientilism.
  • 2 They should put to the people an alternative model of PR that does not pit members of the same party against each other at election time. They are obliged to pledge themselves to deliver more favours to sectional interests. There are list systems that do not subject candidates to the tyranny of tiny pressure groups while preserving the principle of proportionality.
  • 3 In a system that does not require candidates of the same party to outpoll each other, it logically follows that fewer legislators would be required. Thus the numbers of TDs in ratio to population could be reduced by amending Article 16.2 of the Constitution. A Dáil of, say, 120 members would arguably function more efficiently and effectively than a House of 166 members. Reducing the Dáil by 46 members would save more in salaries than abolishing the Seanad.
  • 4 The parliamentary working year should mirror the real world of work. Last year the Dáil sat for 123 days. In 2012 it sat for just 99 days. Even the House of Commons, no great model of industry, sat for 150 days. A private sector employee working a five-day week, allowing for public holidays and for four weeks leave, would work 226 days in the year. Because the House’s sitting days are so few there is a constant pressure on debating time. The majority of Bills are guillotined. In effect, most legislation is rubber-stamped and goes through on the nod.
  • 5 They should abandon the myriad system of members’ allowances which at best generates cynicism and is, at worst, open to abuse. There should be a fixed rate for the job, with inbuilt provision for mileage, accommodation, telephones, office supports, research etc. There is a long and questionable tradition in the Irish public service of viewing allowances and expenses as untaxed income. The Oireachtas should take a lead by consigning it to history. Arguments that deputies living in Dublin would be advantaged over their rural counterparts are marginal but could be addressed.
  • 6 Remuneration should be related to registering a minimum number of attendances during the parliamentary term. Due allowance should be made for certified illness, family bereavements and necessary public commitments elsewhere. The same rules for attendance at work should apply for TDs as for other public servants. If a deputy’s pay depended on Dáil attendance, it might be surprising to find how many funerals could take place and how many supermarkets might be opened without their presence.
  • 7 Like any business, the Government should put the State’s financial plan before their stakeholders for consideration every year. The budget should be published in full and in advance, allowing adequate time for public discussion and analysis. The farce of supposedly dramatic revelations on a Wednesday afternoon is simply an aping of a Westminster tradition in which the chancellor of the exchequer flourishes a brief case for the cameras. It is an anachronism that places unnecessary stresses on businesses.
  • 8 It should be mandatory for each member of a numerically reduced Dáil to participate (without additional financial inducement) in the workings of at least one Oireachtas committee. There is a large cohort of “Wednesday Wonders” who clock in for two days a week, and who rarely contribute to debate.
  • 9 All meetings of the cabinet and cabinet subcommittees should be electronically recorded. If it can be done in the Oval Office at the White House it can be done in the Sycamore Room on Merrion Street. Arrangements could be made to have data stored under some form of judicial supervision. As matters stand we will probably never discover what happened in September 2008 when a cabal of ministers took the decision to pledge the people’s resources to support the banking system.
  • 10 They should abolish the arcane privilege, enshrined in Article 15.13, of members’ immunity from arrest when going to or returning from either House of the Oireachtas. There has never been an instance in the history of the State in which the gardaí have sought to detain an elected representative in order to prevent them exercising their duty. The only known cases in which immunity was claimed appear to have related to drink-driving.
(For completeness, it should be acknowledged that RM Smyllie, later to be editor of The Irish Times, prevented Sligo TD, Alderman John Jinks from reaching the Dáil. By plying him with alcohol, he reputedly prevented him from attending the House for a crucial vote that could have brought down the Government of WT Cosgrave in 1927.)
None of the foregoing measures should be beyond the capacity of a Government with a strong Dáil majority. But this sort of programme would trench in upon traditional and long-established privileges and comforts. So sauce for the business goose is not going to be sauce for the parliamentary gander.

Turf cut on protected bogs in the west and midlands in defiance of EU

 

Over 30 turf cutters gathered at a bog at Kilteevan near Roscommon town. 

There have been a number of incidents on bogs in the midlands and the west today, with turf cut on protected sites.
Gardaí maintained a presence at Monivea bog in Co Galway all day where around 100 people gathered to cut turf in defiance of the EU Habitats Directive.
Bog owners say more than 70 banks of were cut during the course of the day, but turf-cutting equipment has now been taken away.
Under the 1992 Habitats Directive, the 53 Special Areas of Conservation were designated between 1997 and 2002.
Local bog owners who oppose the ban were joined by supporters from Counties Galway, Clare and Roscommon.
Earlier today, gardaí left a bog at Kilteevan, Co Roscommon where they were denied access to turf cutting on protected sites.
A spokesperson said gardaí had gathered information and their investigation would continue.
Pete Gillooly from the Turf Cutters and Contractors Association told RTÉ the local turf cutters were cutting on the site today because they had been offered no alternative sites to cut turf on despite commitments.

Ireland’s reputation up to 12th in the world after G8 summit

      

G8 countries have voted Ireland as the 12th most reputable country in the world. Ireland improved three places from last year’s 15th and is ranked ahead of the UK, France, Spain and Portugal.

Citizens in the G8 nations were asked about a range of issues, not just economic factors, but also political, social and cultural issues. “This is a positive step for Ireland to continue to attract foreign investment and acquire new opportunities for sustained economic growth,” said Niamh Boyle, managing director of Corporate Reputation.

Irish clinic says it will offer the ‘three-parent’ IVF procedures. 

     

THE NEW PROCEDURE COULD PREVENT GENETIC DISORDERS, BUT CRITICS WARN OF ETHICAL ISSUES.


At least one Irish clinic says it will have the capacity to offer a controversial new procedure that allows doctors create IVF babies using genetic material from three people.
The development – known as mitochondrial transfer – uses a small amount of DNA from a female donor to prevent mothers passing on genetic disorders such as muscular dystrophy and heart conditions.
Mitochondrial diseases are incurable and, up to now, there has been no way to prevent them being inherited. About one in 6,500 people is born with a mitochondrial disorder.
Scientists have hailed the procedure as a breakthrough and as a new way of bringing hope to families affected by life-threatening genetic disease

ETHICAL CONCERNS

HOWEVER, OPPONENTS SAY THE PROCEDURE IS UNETHICAL AND COULD SET DOCTORS ON A “SLIPPERY SLOPE” TOWARDS DESIGNER BABIES.
The British government is planning to push ahead with plans to make mitochondrial transfer available. Draft regulations are due to be published later this year, and the procedure could be offered within two years.
There are no laws in Ireland to govern assisted human reproduction. However, IVF clinics would need authorisation from the Irish Medicines Board in order to comply with EU-wide rules over the use and storage of human tissue.
The technique would give a baby DNA from a father, a mother and a female egg donor to eradicate mitochondrial disorders that are debilitating and fatal.
Children born after the procedures would possess nuclear DNA inherited from their parents plus a relatively small amount of mitochondrial DNA from the female egg donor.
The donor’s genetic material would be very small – just 37 genes. The majority of our DNA – the 23,000 genes that shape our appearance – is held separately inside the cell nucleus.
Dr Simon Fishel of the Beacon Care Fertility clinic in Dublin – linked to Britain’s largest independent provider of fertility treatment – said it had the capacity to deliver the new technique in Ireland. But he said the clinic would provide the service only if there was public support for the move, and if the Irish Medicines Board authorised it to do so.

‘GOOD NEWS STORY’

He said the new technique was a good news story for families and rejected suggestions that children’s DNA would be dramatically altered as a result. “One analogy is that it’s like fixing a car. You recognise the car, it’s got the same brand, heritage and appearance. All you’ve changed is a fuel cell in the engine,” he said.
Dr David Walsh of the Sims Clinic in Dublin said there was likely to be very limited demand for the procedure here given our relatively small population. “This is quite specialised and rare. It’s something that is probably best done in a jurisdiction where there’s a much larger population,” he said.
In the UK, for example, it is estimated that about one in 200 children is born each year with a mitochondrial disorder. Not all suffer serious symptoms and not all the girls among them will pass the condition to their offspring.
The new procedure was pioneered in the UK by researchers at Newcastle University.
Some groups have expressed opposition to the procedure on the basis that it crosses a line in medicine by making genetic modifications to an embryo that will pass down to all future generations.
Dr David King, the director of the London-based Human Genetics Alert, said the techniques were unnecessary and unsafe and could lead society on a “slippery slope” to other forms of genetic modification.

Something strange is going on in Donegal? Dead dolphin body appears inland at Leffin

       

ANIMAL CARCASS BAFFLES LOCALS AFTER IT IS FOUND MILES INSHORE IN CO DONEGAL 

The dead dolphin, or killer whale, has baffled locals at Leffin, Co Donegal,
The dead creature was discovered at Meenbanad near Burtonport.
The dolphin, which has distinctive black and white markings, has injuries to its head but it is not known how it died.
It had been thought locally it was a young killer whale. The area where the creature was found is known as The Leifin, which has a council waterworks close by.
Local woman Niamh Bonner, who found the dolphin, said people are baffled as to how it ended up in the hills.
She said: “It had to be dragged there because it is about 100 yards off the road. The Leifin is about two miles from any coastline.”
Padraig Whooley of the Irish Whale and Dolphin Group thinks it is part of a group of Atlantic white-sided dolphins which beached at nearby Traigheanna Bay in Dungloe on June 21.
Mr Whooley said sightings of such dolphins are fairly uncommon as they tend to stay much further out to sea.

He added: “It could have been taken to this remote area so it could decompose naturally leaving a skeleton which could have been put on show.”